Comparing Horses to People

The death of Eight Belles has garnered a lot of attention around the sports world recently, so I figure I’ll jump in on this hot topic. I realize this is a touchy issue for many people, so feel free to agree or disagree with me in the comments.

I will start off by saying that the death of Eight Belles is nothing short of a tragedy and I feel terrible for the owners, trainer, and jockey. All this talk of PETA trying to get the jockey, Gabriel Saez, suspended is crazy to me. If anyone saw the post-race interviews they could clearly see how much the people involved were shaken. I’m not horse racing aficionado, but I know that if there was anything that could have been done to avoid the situation, it would have been done with no hesitation. Woody Paige mentioned on ESPN’s Around the Horn today that on average, something like two thoroughbred horses are euthanized in the USA per day. I would be all for an investigation as to why this number is so high. I just don’t think suspending the jockey who tried to pull the horse up when he felt something was wrong would get anything accomplished.

Having said all that, there is one thing that has really bothered me about this whole process. On at least three occasions I have heard the following analogy: This would be the same thing as if the quarterback collapsed and died in the locker room after the Super Bowl. Bill Plaschke said it. Eight Belles’ owner said it. Several ESPN anchors said it. To them I say, “No. It’s not the same. At all.” Eight Belles’ death was tragic and terrible, but she was a horse. That quarterback would be a human. There is no comparison whatsoever. If Plaschke was given the choice of letting a horse be euthanized or letting any football player collapse and die, he would pick the horse every single time. It’s morbid, I know, but it just proves the point. This analogy they keep using is terrible and I wish they would stop and think about what they’re saying before they say it.

Now that you see what I think, let me know how you feel. Think the horse’s life is more valuable than Tom Brady’s? Weller, don’t answer, but all the rest of you leave a comment.


8 Responses

  1. Can we atleast get a choice of QB? A horse or Peyton Manning, it’d obviously be Manning

  2. You are right. There is no comparison between the lives of animals and the lives of people. While we all love our animals, their life would be sacrificed every time over that of a human being. Give up the fight though. People love to argue and this will drag on and on. Only when it is YOUR loved one will there be a difference.

  3. I think that a better sports comparison to the Kentucky Derby tragedy is Dale Earnhardt hitting the wall during the final lap of his last race. The fact that he lost his life in what appeared to be a minor crash is still shocking and sad…but like Eight Belles…

    it was an ACCIDENT!

  4. Peyton Manning looks like a horse, and plays for the colts. I’d rather see Manning go, than the horse.

  5. Oh, and as for Brady. The horse wins again.

  6. Horseworks:
    I agree, that’s a better way to look at this. It is still a Dale Earnhardt-Eight Belles comparison, but I will agree that it makes more sense. The difference is that Nascar looked into what happened and were able to make changes to the sport. That’s how the Han’s Device came about. I’m not sure what horse racing can do to stop accidents like this one.

  7. […] Our first hotly debated post was one relating to a sport neither of us knows anything about.  Horse Racing. […]

  8. I didn’t even dare to get in on this conversation, lol.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: